City Cast DC logo

The Fight Over U Street’s Future

Posted on April 18, 2024   |   Updated on September 30, 2025
Natalia Aldana

Natalia Aldana

The site of a contentious redevelopment showdown, at 1617 U St. NW, Washington, D.C. (Google Maps)

The site of a contentious redevelopment showdown, at 1617 U St. NW, Washington, D.C. (Google Maps)

To build, or not to build? That is the big question for the site of an unsightly old firehouse and police station on U Street where the city has proposed a 10-story building with 36,000 housing units by 2028, including affordable units.

While there’s no actual proposal or developer, the mayor is proposing a change to the zoning laws to build as high as 100 feet. That possibility sent shockwaves through the community, as the Zoning Commission has heard about 30 hours of testimony, 700 exhibits, letters, and petitions against this change. Concerns range from the physical shadow the building could create to how market-rate rentals could displace existing residents. But many also want to see the unattractive and long abandoned property on the edge of Adams Morgan replaced, recognizing D.C. desperately needs more affordable housing.

The Washington Post’s Paul Schwartzman joined City Cast DC and walked us through the wild details surrounding this controversy. As he and host Michael Schaffer discussed on the podcast, this debate also raises the question of “what version of D.C. do we want to be?”

🎧 Affordable housing, but for whom?
see more:housing

Share article

Hey DC

Get smart about D.C. with our news roundup and analysis.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

Local Civics

See All
Local CivicsApril 13

Why the Holocaust Museum Self-Censored Before Trump Even Asked

The Holocaust Museum has been quietly changing its content since President Trump returned to office to avoid drawing the administration’s...

The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. (ajay_suresh/Wikimedia Commons)
Local CivicsMarch 25

Malcolm X Park Closure Sparks Community Outcry

Most of Malcolm X Park is closing until early summer for repairs. Here is everything we know so you can plan your picnic in peace.

Enjoying the park before it closes. (Kaela Cote-Stemmermann/City Cast DC)
Local CivicsMarch 16

In Controversial Move, FBI Sends New Grads to Patrol DC

The FBI just announced that it's sending its upcoming agent class from Quantico to do a 60-day foot patrol rotation in D.C. alongside loc...

FBI officers seen walking in LeDroit Park. (The Washington Post/Getty Images)
Local CivicsMarch 9

The McMillan Development Is Finally Here — Will It Live Up To the Hype?

For more than a decade the McMillan filtration site was one of D.C.’s ugliest political battles. Now, the redevelopment is here, but will...

A new housing development at the old McMillan site in Washington, DC (The Washington Post/Getty Images)
Local CivicsFebruary 26

The Downfall of DC's Compass Coffee

Last week, British coffee chain Caffè Nero bought Compass Coffee at auction after it went bankrupt.

Outside of a Compass Coffee at 650 F. (The Washington Post/Getty Images)
Local CivicsFebruary 5

Jeff Bezos Gutted the Washington Post. Now What?

The Post, owned by Jeff Bezos, laid off up to a third of its staff.

Washington Post building located on K Street NW. (The Washington Post/Getty Images)
Local CivicsFebruary 2

Eleanor Holmes Norton’s Son Also Wanted Her to Retire

D.C.’s Congressional Delegate Eleanor Holmes Norton announced last week that she’s not going to run again.

Eleanor Holmes Norton speaks during a press conference about the deployment of the National Guard. (The Washington Post/Getty Images)
Local CivicsJanuary 29

Can the Kennedy Center Survive Trump?

This week, Composer Philip Glass, a 2018 Kennedy Center honoree renowned for his pioneering contributions to modern music, announced he n...

US President Donald Trump sits at the center of a long table and presides over a board meeting at the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts in Washington, DC, on March 17, 2025. He is surrounded by five people on each side.